- Home
- Share
- Forum
- Depression Forum
- Treatments for depression
- Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) for depression
Patients Depression
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) for depression
- 24 views
- 4 times supported
- 4 comments
All comments
Courtney_J
Community managerGood advisor
Courtney_J
Community manager
Last activity on 13/10/2022 at 16:47
Joined in 2020
1,280 comments posted | 67 in the Depression Forum
10 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
-
Good Advisor
-
Contributor
-
Messenger
-
Committed
-
Explorer
-
Evaluator
Hello @whitecross1955, thank you for opening this discussion, I've moved it to our depression treatments group for more visibility. Is ECT something you're interested in trying or have tried already?
If you haven't already seen it, we published an article a few months ago on ECT explaining how it works and some of the controversy around it: What is electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)?
Take care,
Courtney
See the signature
Courtney_J, Community Manager, Carenity UK
whitecross1955
Good advisor
whitecross1955
Last activity on 06/11/2024 at 20:25
Joined in 2016
169 comments posted | 23 in the Depression Forum
7 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
-
Good Advisor
-
Contributor
-
Committed
-
Explorer
-
Friend
-
Newsfeeder
@Courtney_J Thank you Courtney I posted it in the wrong place, sorry about that, Years back I was in a private hospital for people with different mental health issues, Got chatting to a young man every day who was been treated for depression Seems the medication was not making him any better. and his family agreed to E.C.T. Met him a few days later after a few sessions, he could not speak a word, did not remember my name or where he was. I was shocked. I was under the care of a psychiatrist and asked him about this treatment his reply was over the years he had met people some of who had 100 sessions and were not better. He considered the results let to closed head electrical injury
Raindrops
Good advisor
Raindrops
Last activity on 10/04/2023 at 17:44
Joined in 2020
29 comments posted | 24 in the Depression Forum
1 of their responses was helpful to members
Rewards
-
Good Advisor
-
Contributor
-
Messenger
-
Explorer
@whitecross1955 I didn't know they were stil doing this kind of treatment and I can understand the controversy around it. It make you think of one flew over the cuckoo's next and the like. I assume that it does help some if they keep offering it, but it's not something I'm interested in.
whitecross1955
Good advisor
whitecross1955
Last activity on 06/11/2024 at 20:25
Joined in 2016
169 comments posted | 23 in the Depression Forum
7 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
-
Good Advisor
-
Contributor
-
Committed
-
Explorer
-
Friend
-
Newsfeeder
@Raindrops Some hospitals use it., This barbaric treatment is the endgame where a psychiatrist has given up on the patient. accordingly to one psychiatrist, he has met people who had over 100 treatments and were no better. Psychiatrist have lost their way when they only use medications and not be open to other treatments Not taken into account what the upbringing of the patient was like, their worries personal and financial, their relationships or lack of them. If your only tool is a hammer, then everything looks like a nail
Give your opinion
Members are also commenting on...
jenlei14
I take each day as it comes, try to have a focus for that day. Today is pretty good, but it gives me a nudge every now and again. H
See the best comment
jenlei14
I take each day as it comes, try to have a focus for that day. Today is pretty good, but it gives me a nudge every now and again. H
See the best comment
Articles to discover...
11/11/2024 | Advice
27/05/2024 | Procedures & paperwork
27/10/2023 | News
24/05/2023 | Testimonial
Multi conditions: “My voice is loud for those who have been silenced.”
27/06/2016 | News
People with depression are 60% more likely to develop diabetes
19/05/2017 | Testimonial
19/05/2017 | Testimonial
26/10/2018 | Advice
Medication fact sheets - patient opinions...
Subscribe
You wish to be notified of new comments
Your subscription has been taken into account
whitecross1955
Good advisor
whitecross1955
Last activity on 06/11/2024 at 20:25
Joined in 2016
169 comments posted | 23 in the Depression Forum
7 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
Good Advisor
Contributor
Committed
Explorer
Friend
Newsfeeder
The American psychiatrist Thomas Szasz wrote "electricity as a form of treatments based on force and fraud and justified by "medical necessity "the cost of this functionalization runs high. It requires the sacrifice of the patient as a person of the psychiatrist as a clinical thinker and moral agent".An electric current of between 70 -400 volts is passed through the brain to cause a major epileptic seizure. The current is administered for a fraction of a second or several seconds. To avoid muscle spasm that would crack vertebrae, break bones and damage teeth, sedation with a short-acting intravenous barbiturate followed byby muscle paralysis and respiration with oxygen .