«
»

Top

Spain's Catalonia in raw milk controversy

Published 25 Jul 2018

Spain's Catalonia in raw milk controversy

Madrid, July 25, 2018 (AFP) - Catalonia is in the eye of the storm again, but not for its independence drive. This time, the controversy is all about... raw milk.

milk

The Spanish region's decision last Thursday to allow the sale of unpasteurised cow's milk directly from producers to consumers after it was banned 28 years ago has caused alarm due to the potential health risks involved.

Spanish media has published article after article outlining the bacteria-induced danger, health experts have come out against it and the issue has gone viral on Twitter, echoing similar vivid debates in countries such as the United States.

Catalonia's food and agriculture regional minister Teresa Jorda argues raw milk has "spectacular" health properties and is safe due to the "technological improvements in farming equipment" and strict hygiene standards.

"There is the same level of danger as opening the fridge, grabbing a chicken thigh which has been there for four weeks and eating it," she told Catalonia's RAC1 radio on Sunday. But critics are sceptical.

They retort drinking raw milk is dangerous as it can transmit potentially deadly bacteria such as salmonella, E.coli, and even illnesses like bovine tuberculosis -- which is why pasteurisation was introduced in the first place in the early 1900s.

On Tuesday, Spain's health ministry revealed that a decree allowing the sale of   raw milk nationwide had been in the works under the previous conservative government.

But the new Socialist executive has decided to suspend this until a "full analysis" of the issue is done, it said in a statement.
This suspension does not affect the decision in Catalonia, which has autonomy in food safety matters.

Help small farmers

Jorda also argues the measure will help small farmers increase their earnings as they will be selling milk directly to customers.
Spain's UPA small farmers' union has asked for the measure to be implemented nationwide.

It says Spain's livestock are in good condition which means drinking raw milk is safe, "always bearing in mind the milk must be boiled and preserved correctly -- a maximum of 72 hours from milking -- to eliminate potential micro-organisms".

But Gemma del Cano, a food safety expert who works in the food industry, points out this is a complex process as it involves boiling the milk three times, then making sure the temperature goes down quickly.

She stresses it's a fine line between boiling the milk so it kills all bacteria and over-boiling it which will kill all nutrients, hence the usefulness of pasteurisation, a heating process which proponents deny destroys the goodness of milk.

Further afield, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in the United States, where many states allow raw milk, warns strongly against it.

"Germs can multiply and grow in milk between the time it's collected and when someone drinks it," it says on its website.
It adds "healthy animals may carry germs that can make people sick".

According to its most recent statistics from 2007 to 2016, "32 states reported 144 outbreaks linked to raw milk".

In Europe, raw milk is legally available in France and Italy.

AFP (Agence France Presse)

6 comments


lesmal • Ambassador
on 29/07/2018

An interesting but also controversial article.

I can't ever see myself agreeing to drinking raw milk; especially after being brought up on pasteurised milk for several years. I would rather not drink milk at all.

I don't see raw milk being healthy and safe.


avatar
Unregistered member
on 29/08/2018

Many farmer friends of mine take milk straight from the tank in the dairy before the tanker arrives to collect it. Several times I have been given cream straight off the top of the tank, and yes THAT'S CREAMY...... I seem OK with it, as do my friends. Providing the dairy on the farm is kept clean. I don't really see a problem.

We drank it for centuries before pasteurisation.

Sorry, that's my take on it....


avatar
Unregistered member
on 03/09/2018

I was born and brought up in India where the small farmers delivered milk  straight from the tank. Fortunately neither me nor any of my 4 siblings were affected in any way. As I became a teenager, our parents did go in to buying pasteurized milk though. My thoughts on it today is, Raw milk is not safe to drink, even though it is legal in France and Italy 


JosephineO • Community manager
on 06/09/2018

It is interesting to see the different views and experiences surrounding unpasteurised milk.


Pippadog • Ambassador
on 24/09/2018

This is a controversial subject, I think people who have been brought up drinking raw milk should be able to continue to do so. For those people who have an impaired immunity should not drink raw milk because of the risk of infections. People who have been brought up on pasteurised milk should make tha decision themselves.

You will also like

The Hypotoxic (Seignalet) diet: Is it effective for certain chronic illnesses?

The Hypotoxic (Seignalet) diet: Is it effective for certain chronic illnesses?

Read the article
What should we eat to sleep well?

What should we eat to sleep well?

Read the article
Is breakfast really the most important meal of the day?

Is breakfast really the most important meal of the day?

Read the article
What should we eat to feed our brains?

What should we eat to feed our brains?

Read the article

Most commented discussions