- Home
- Share
- Forum
- General forums
- Good to know
- Butter: Could it be worse than plant based oils for your health? ๐ง
Butter: Could it be worse than plant based oils for your health? ๐ง
- 43 views
- 0 support
- 3 comments
All comments
Scotty 2
Good advisor
Scotty 2
Last activity on 17/03/2025 at 21:56
Joined in 2015
69 comments posted | 9 in the Good to know group
8 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
-
Good Advisor
-
Contributor
-
Committed
-
Explorer
-
Friend
Who sponsored this report?
Close all
See the responses
robjmckinney
AmbassadorGood advisor
robjmckinney
Ambassador
Last activity on 25/03/2025 at 18:47
Joined in 2015
617 comments posted | 99 in the Good to know group
52 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
-
Good Advisor
-
Contributor
-
Messenger
-
Committed
-
Explorer
-
Evaluator
@Scotty 2 The right question!
See the signature
robjmckinney
Hide the responses
robjmckinney
AmbassadorGood advisor
robjmckinney
Ambassador
Last activity on 25/03/2025 at 18:47
Joined in 2015
617 comments posted | 99 in the Good to know group
52 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
-
Good Advisor
-
Contributor
-
Messenger
-
Committed
-
Explorer
-
Evaluator
The so called experts need to sort themselves out as they seem to change the minds far to often. For years margerine was the healthy option not butter, then the new spreads, then they finally agreed butter was always the best option. Having converted to the so called healthy options over the last 50 years only to be refered back to butter, the experts can get lost. Is it like when they gave rats gallong of certain sugar substitutes one or two developed cancer. Everything we eat/drink carries a health risk and the so called experts seem to change their minds weekly. So no, I won't be taking notice of this latest claim, I am back on full fat milk and butter, like I started with nearly 70 years ago!
See the signature
robjmckinney
Give your opinion
Survey
Articles to discover...

14/03/2025 | Nutrition
Carbohydrates: Friend or foe? Everything you need to know to make the right choices!
Subscribe
You wish to be notified of new comments
Your subscription has been taken into account
Somya.P
Community managerGood advisor
Somya.P
Community manager
Last activity on 25/03/2025 at 22:43
Joined in 2023
559 comments posted | 179 in the Good to know group
44 of their responses were helpful to members
Rewards
Good Advisor
Contributor
Messenger
Explorer
Friend
Hi everyone, how are you doing lately? ๐
A new study suggests that butter may increase the risk of early death, while plant-based oils could offer health benefits. Researchers tracked over 221,000 people for more than 30 years and found:
However, not all plant-based oils are equal, olive oil, soybean oil, and canola oil showed benefits, while corn and safflower oils did not. If you're wondering which oils are best for your health, hereโs an article that breaks it down for you:
๐ The 6 Best Cooking Oils and Fats to Support Your Health
Do you use butter regularly, or have you switched to plant-based oils?
@steven elvin @Yank34 @Hunterad @ladyann @Peggylea @chelle1503 @woundedhealer @Silverlady @hackie54 @gerri2011 @laney365 @Tim Want @madpete @LynneC @lil steph @TabbyCat @susanian @Patr1ck @Juneyred @helsinki @carrmacc @cuck118 @Dogger @Tigger.co.uk @harpingmad @Bonzo1939 @Cappoo @Patsy1963 @KPangela @smokitcat @nickynoo @Dolphin74 @Ibanez6uk @Lylabow123 @mikesalmons @Jules2012 @PatHarry @Hallokathotmail.com @nanawoody @Leanneh @mmullane @Ann-marie @hockeygoalie @hayles @Jackki @Ck0bbb @FARMER3752 @lunnii @chrissie2018 @Malcolmx @amsmith @Trickynicky @percival4 @Stewpot @MarkClayt @Dalrossi @Bellarousk @brightvb @EllieMay1959 @Gwylie @Sarahm @Skala37 @Helen0604 @StevieC @cwright17 @Nicolamennell @littlemisskitty @ColinSalter @Houndlover @Nicwoz74 @Loyell @SunshineW @Rory289 @Elk217015 @shirtz @Lizann @nnickyrose68 @SianPhillips @jimbob @Timann @SP3RDN4 @Herondoll @Ronnie49 @Taliaaa @mickyf @JanBotha @Ashy51 @MrStuartCook @Blue @ColinOld @Dwright @PeterC @anddym @Craigsif @stew53 @Cleverdick @BrianBart @PhilipW @Karen6797
Looking forward to your thoughts,
Somya from the Carenity Team ๐ผ
Source: Zhang Y,ย Chadaideh KS,ย Li Y, et al. Butter and Plant-Based Oils Intake and Mortality.ย JAMA Intern Med.ย Published online March 06, 2025.